A new report released on Monday has named Brooklyn as the city’s leading borough for premium pizza. The ranking, compiled by a national food publication, placed several Brooklyn shops above their Manhattan and Queens counterparts.

The study surveyed over 100 pizzerias, focusing on quality, consistency, and customer feedback. Popular shops in neighborhoods like Carroll Gardens, Greenpoint, and Bay Ridge received particular mention. Prices for a slice at these top spots now often range from $4 to $6, reflecting higher ingredient costs this fall.

On Tuesday afternoon, crowds outside Lucali and L&B Spumoni Gardens were steady, with some customers citing the new ranking as a reason for their visit. “I read about it this morning and decided to come by,” said Maria Lopez, a teacher from Flatbush, waiting in line on Henry Street.

While Manhattan remains a draw for tourists seeking classic slices, the report suggests Brooklyn’s independent operators are setting the standard for quality. Some in the industry point to the borough’s wood-fired ovens and commitment to traditional techniques as key reasons for its strong showing this season.

With the election cycle and colder weather approaching, pizza shop owners say they expect demand to remain high on weeknights, especially among commuters and students returning home. For now, Brooklyn’s pizza scene appears to have the city’s attention.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which borough was named the best for pizza in New York City according to the latest report?

Brooklyn was named the top borough for premium pizza in New York City according to the latest report.

What criteria were used to rank the pizzerias in the survey?

The survey focused on quality, consistency, and customer feedback to rank the pizzerias.

Which Brooklyn neighborhoods were highlighted for their pizza shops?

Carroll Gardens, Greenpoint, and Bay Ridge were the Brooklyn neighborhoods specifically mentioned.

How much does a slice of pizza cost at top Brooklyn spots mentioned in the report?

Prices for a slice at top Brooklyn spots now range from $4 to $6.

Which Brooklyn pizza shops saw increased crowds after the ranking was published?

Lucali and L&B Spumoni Gardens saw increased crowds after the ranking was published.

Editorial Transparency. A first draft of this story was produced with AI-assisted writing tools, then reviewed for accuracy and tone by the named editor before publication. More on our process: Editorial Policy.