With the start of fall and cooler evenings settling over New York, home cooks are beginning to plan for the holiday season. This week, a panel of tasters sampled seven widely available boxed stuffing mixes, including brands such as Stove Top, Pepperidge Farm, and Trader Joe’s. The tasting, conducted by Bon Appétit staff, aimed to determine which boxed mix should earn a spot at city tables this autumn.
Tasters prepared each stuffing according to package directions. Judging criteria included texture, flavor, and aroma. The panel found that three brands stood out from the rest, though all were described as serviceable for weeknight meals or larger gatherings.
Stove Top’s classic herb mix was noted for its balanced seasoning and soft, consistent texture. Pepperidge Farm’s offering was praised for its larger bread pieces, which held up well after baking. Trader Joe’s stuffing earned points for a more pronounced sage flavor, though its texture was described as slightly denser than the others.
With supply chain issues easing at local supermarkets, most brands are in stock at major retailers across the city. Packages currently retail from $2.99 to $5.49, depending on brand and location. Store managers at Morton Williams and Foodtown in Manhattan report steady sales as shoppers prepare for early gatherings.
As the city heads into the final week of September, many residents are balancing work, school, and meal planning. For some, opting for a boxed stuffing mix remains a practical choice, especially for smaller kitchens and tight schedules.
Leave a Comment